Morganite vs Moissanite: What's The Difference?

Choosing the right gemstone for an engagement ring is likely the most important jewelry decision you will ever make. It’s likely also one of the most expensive decisions you’ll ever make. However, there are several more affordable alternatives to diamonds nowadays, giving you a lot more options for a truly spectacular ring. 

A top comparison among engagement rings is that of morganite vs. moissanite. Let's look at the difference between morganite and moissanite so we can help you decide which one is best for that special someone in your life.

Morganite vs. Moissanite: Where Do They Come From?

Morganite doesn't come from the same place as moissanite. A morganite stone is a natural gemstone, while moissanite is sustainably grown in a laboratory. Although moissanite was originally discovered as a natural gemstone when it was first found in a meteor crater, it doesn't occur naturally in large enough quantities to produce jewelry.

Both moissanite vs. morganite are real gemstones because of their chemical composition and crystal structure, so don't be fooled into thinking that moissanite is "fake". However, being that it’s produced in a laboratory, moissanite is a more ethically sourced choice. It doesn't have the same concerns as diamonds, which require mining that harms the environment and uses profits to fund conflicts in war zones.

Similar to diamonds, morganite is a natural gemstone that requires mining. It’s a member of the colorful beryl family of gemstones, which also includes emeralds, aquamarine, and golden beryl. Morganite was first discovered in Madagascar, but now it commonly comes from Brazil.

Morganite vs Moissanite

Morganite is a diamond simulant that closely resembles a pink diamond. Moissanite appears very similar to a diamond but exhibits more significant fire. Its exceptional hardness and colorless nature make it a compelling alternative to diamonds.

morganite vs moissanite

Moissanite

Because moissanite is a lab-grown gemstone, it is produced under controlled conditions that allow for a truly optimal stone. Here are the benefits of choosing moissanite vs. morganite:

Clarity

When talking about clarity, we're looking at the number of imperfections in the gemstone known as inclusions (internal) or blemishes (external). Because moissanite is produced in a laboratory, it’s possible to control the process and eliminate any imperfections; thus producing a higher-clarity gemstone every time.

Color

Moissanites are a colorless gemstone similar to diamonds. They can have undertones ranging from green to yellow to gray if you prefer a gemstone with a slight tint.

Durability

Durability refers to how hard a particular gemstone is, and is rated on a scale called the Mohs hardness scale. The harder the gemstone, the less likely it is to get scratched or suffer visible damage. Moissanite is second only to natural diamonds in terms of hardness, rating 9.5 on the Mohs scale, while diamonds top out the scale at 10.

Morganite

What is morganite? It gets its name from the famous business tycoon J.P. Morgan, who was a gemstone enthusiast. It’s one of the more unique alternatives to diamonds in engagement rings, because it doesn't really look like a diamond at all thanks to its blush-colored hue. 

Is morganite expensive? As with all gemstones, its price is dependent on the four C’s: color, clarity, cut, and carat. However, if you're comparing morganite price vs. diamond price, morganite is certainly the more affordable option.

Clarity

In terms of morganite vs. moissanite, morganite is naturally sourced and not produced in a laboratory. However, morganite generally forms with what are known as clean crystals, so there are usually few imperfections visible to the naked eye.

Color

One of the most obvious differences when comparing morganite vs. moissanite and morganite vs. diamond is that morganite is a colored beryl gemstone sometimes called rose beryl, with a peach or pink hue. It’s therefore a more unusual and less traditional choice for an engagement ring.

Durability

Do you want to see where morganite is on the Mohs scale? Morganite's hardness rating is 7.5 to 8 on the Mohs scale, calling it a sturdy choice for jewelry, provided it is handled carefully to prevent scratches and impacts.

Which is Best for an Engagement Ring?

Which one is best depends on preference. Whichever one you think is best is the choice for you. Here’s a quick breakdown to help you decide between a diamond, morganite and moissanite ring for your special someone:

Moissanite vs. Morganite

  • Moissanite is more durable and generally has greater clarity
  • Morganite has a delicate pink to peach color range, making it a unique and non-traditional choice
  • Morganite is the slightly less expensive option, but moissanite is more similar to a diamond

Morganite vs. Diamond

  • Morganite is a colored gemstone (pinkish hues) while a diamond is a colorless stone
  • Morganite is significantly less expensive than diamond
  • Diamonds are a more traditional choice for an engagement ring

Your Perfect Engagement Ring is Waiting at Gema&Co

Looking for an engagement ring is exciting. You’re about to start a new life with someone special, so make sure to give them something special. Take the time to shop the premium selection of moissanite engagement rings at Gema&Co, where you'll find a variety of beautiful cuts to match the style you're looking for. A moissanite engagement ring sparkles like no other gemstone, making it the perfect choice for truly unforgettable jewelry. Contact us today to learn more.
Back to blog